- Resources for Farmers
- Resources for Educators
- Resources for the Public
- GIM Workshops
- Grown in Marin Newsletter PDFs
- Grown in Marin Newsletter Articles
Archived Related News Items
- 5 Stops on a California Cheese Trail
- Double sofi Gold Awards For Point Reyes Farmstead Cheese
- Bay Area wheat makes a comeback
- Cowgirl Creamery's founders blend traits
- Where less product is better
- Go Ahead, Milk My Day
- Stanford study unlikely to slow momentum of Marin's organic food movement
- Work to keep cattle away from creeks seeks to improve water quality in West Marin
- Marin's Green Gulch, a pioneer in organic farming, celebrates 40 years
- FoodWorks Finds New Markets for Local Growers
- New generation of West Marin ranchers coming back to the family farm
- Cream of the Crop
- Surge in gopher population in Tam Valley
- Sowing organic seeds of success at College of Marin's Novato campus
- Local food: No elitist plot
- Rethinking the farm
- New canning company helps preserve Marin's farms
- He's Full of It
- UC Davis launches agricultural sustainability degree
- Working from the heart: The legacy of a Point Reyes farming family
- Meat Distribution Part 2: Technology on the Range
- Making a cheese statement
- College of Marin launches apprentice program for farmers
- The future of Gravenstein apples hangs on a thin stem
- Across the Bay Area, urban farming is in season
- Fresh from the farm
- New farmers find their footing
- Could farms survive without illegal labor?
- IVC's organic farm is Project of the Year
- The Unpaid Intern, Legal or Not
- Six Stories Above Queens, a Fine Spot for a Little Farming
- Marin's farmers hang on despite drop in milk prices
- Farm internships in Oregon
- Mature at last, Marin County's cheeses stand alone
- College of Marin leading the whey in cheese education
- Land trust has kept Marin's farms in business for 30 years
- Marin County farmers and ranchers plan for success
- Till life: Marin History Museum's latest exhibit shows why our county ag industry hasn't, er...bought the farm
- College of Marin launches organic farm at Indian Valley campus
- College of Marin's organic farming students get hands-on experience
- Point Reyes workshop aims to put a chicken in every backyard
- After 21 years, UC Extension director turns author
- Coastal meandering
- COM wins grant for farm program
- From the Farm to Your Table: A Consumer’s Guide to Fresh Fruits and Vegetables Publication
- Novato grocer connects with local farmers
- Sonoma County consumers buy locally produced meat
- Dairies feel pinch of climbing costs
- County Line Farm moves west
- You are invited to apply for funding for agricultural worker housing
- The grass isn't always greener
- Goat farm producing natural, sustainable meat
- Non profits help local farms
- A banner year for Marin farms with record revenues for 2007
- MALT closes $2.7 million deal to preserve farmland
- Supervisors commit $200,000 for farmworkers' housing
- Sonoma farm to table
- Take a haycation on a North Bay farm
- Cuisine scene: Marin's bounty ready for its close-up
- Cafeteria Crusaders: They're changing the way kids eat
- Versatile Spuds
- Growing Concern - Some Marin Farmers Market vendors say the economy is slowing business
- Organic Marin - Marin farmers find success with organic food
- It's all about the cheese
- If It’s Fresh and Local, Is It Always Greener?
- Food Conscious: Is Organic Better? It Depends.
- 2007 Census of Agriculture
- The faces behind the farmers
- Now that's natural gas
- Marin experiences an early but fruitful harvest
- UC Examines Cost of Producing Strawberries
- Farmers markets thrive in Marin
- Taste of Marin - 2007 style
- Farm Bill 2007: What it means for Marin - Part I
- Production beginning for UCCE’s Hidden Bounty of Marin documentary
- Toluma Goat Dairy in Tomales
- What will happen to our cattle when the slaughterhouse is gone?
- Pastured eggs catching on
- Marin Sun Farms Newsletter
- Farming on the Edge of Change
- UC researcher: farmers markets benefit local economies
- Family Farms in Peril
- The Farm Bill and California food and agriculture
- California cheeses: the next wave
- The new food crusade
- 847 sheep shorn in nine hours
- Bee news
- UCCE Marin Intern Program welcomes Anne Kehoe
- Farming on the edge . . . of change
- Marin Farmers Market awarded as environmental educator
- Milk cow blues
- W. Marin man hopes frozen sperm takes ranch to 'next level'
- A 'nobody' no more
- Rhapsody in Blue
- Drive-by shooter targets cattle in West Marin
- Cheese unplugged
- Green Giants
- The Faces of Organic/Clover Stornetta Farms
- New kids on the block
- Organic dairy certification workshop
- Demand for organic outruns supply
- Volunteers, with cows in tow, join war on thistle
- New Release Offering – Marin Wines
- Last slaughterhouse closing
- Organic evolution: farming a natural choice for Tomales woman
- Leslie Harlib's Cuisine Scene: Go West
- Leslie Harlib's Social Scene: Festive fund raising, organically
- New high quality feed discovered: Wooly Distaff Thistle
- Organic Dairy Workshop in Tomales
- This time, “grass fed” really means “grass fed.”
- Marin Farm Families- Stories & Recipes
- Organic education: Bolinas, Stinson students to get fresh lunches
- Obesity war's latest battlefront: the school cafeteria School nutrition is activists' passion
- Pampering pumpkins
- Buying Local
- Marin Sonoma Livestock Workgroup
- Taste of Marin - Celebrating Marin County Agriculture
- Renowned author Wendell Berry tours Bolinas farm, applauds agrarian efforts
- Organic Beef — Natural Meat Steaks Its Claim
- Dionisio Choperena -- in ad, life a shepherd
- Back to the ranch
- Going organic
- Ranchers and farmers meet in W. Marin to discuss future of agriculture
- Market growing for Marin olive oil producers, sellers
- Point Reyes Station dairy is losing its cows - and its reputation
- Marin dairy farmers face hard times as corn costs rise
- Is Organic Food Really a Better Buy?
- The Marin Center for Sustainable Agriculture is on its way here
- Farm Bureau lunch to honor our county government & supporters
- A Drop in the Bucket: reclaiming water for farming
- Successful first year at new Worsley Farms location in Point Reyes
- Study examines farms' vitality
- Cheese producers hailed as model for West Marin development
- AGRIBUSINESS - Organic Erosion
- Coming in from the cold
- Tiburon entrepreneur hopes to make cheese where the buffalo roam
- UC ANR Publications
- Photos of Marin Agriculture
Study examines farms' vitality
Marin Independent Journal article
A new study suggests that building massive homes on agricultural lands reduces the property's economic vitality.
The study provides ammunition to county planning officials, who want to discourage wealthy landowners from building mansions, rather than farms, on agricultural lands.
"Those who can afford to buy this property are folks with an outside income, and the purchase of that property is more about aesthetics and a desire to share this culture than it is an interest in viable agriculture," Community Development Director Alex Hinds said.
Hinds and other officials have proposed an update to the Marin Countywide Plan that would restrict housing on agricultural property to 2,500 square feet or less.
But members of the Planning Commission have challenged the new study's conclusions, suggesting that the 2003 analysis does not consistently reflect current economic realities.
Consultant David Strong presented the study to the Planning Commission at their meeting Monday.
Strong's report suggests that large agricultural parcels with large homes tend to produce less, in terms of farm-related income, than large parcels with smaller homes. In addition, their presence tends to drive up the price of other agricultural lands. He concludes that limits on housing size could improve the economic viability of agricultural property.
"If someone wants to build a large house, it's not certain that their interest in agriculture is sincere," said Strong, an Oakland-based consultant.
Because the value of Marin's agricultural land has skyrocketed in recent years, however - while the value of farm products has remained the same or fallen - planning commissioners asked whether any agricultural property could really be considered economically viable.
"Even if you didn't build a house on the property, the land value would be more than any agricultural operation could justify," Commissioner Don Dickenson said.
Strong argued that using land for agriculture lowers its taxable value, making farming operations at least marginally profitable.
The idea of tiny profit margins on county farms worried Commissioner Hank Barner, however.
Barner cited a University of California Cooperative Extension study that said 63 percent of Marin farmers report their operations are "marginally" or "not" profitable.
"When only a small percent of our farmers are turning a profit, we have a problem," Barner said.
Strong countered that Marin's farmers are land-rich, even if many are cash-poor.
"Their day-to-day expenses are like a checking account," Strong said. "But they know they're sitting on one hell of a savings account. It's like having stocks."
Barner was not impressed.
"You can't eat stocks, and you can't eat land appreciation," Barner said. "The general feeling of the testimony I've heard in this room since the '80s is that the agricultural producers of this county are not awash in profit. That's bothersome to me."
Dickenson noted that landowners who build homes on their property pay higher taxes, helping to support county agricultural programs.
Those landowners are also required by law to fulfill other conditions of use, such as allowing other farmers to graze or till their property at reduced rental rates, Dickenson said. The requirements allow farmers who could never afford to buy or even rent agricultural land in Marin the opportunity to stay in business, he said.
"In effect, non-agricultural development helps to subsidize agricultural use," Dickenson said. "That's not reflected in this study."
Other efforts to improve the economics of Marin's farmers and ranchers were achieving mixed results, Strong reported.
While the county had convinced many of its farmers and ranchers to run organic operations - exceeding its own goals by 1,500 percent, Hinds said - the economic advantages those farmers received were being undercut by the decision of large corporate farms to "go organic" themselves.
"We can remember a time when Marin's organic growers sold to Whole Foods Market," Strong said. "As most of you know, those times are gone, now that corporate agriculture has dedicated large parcels to organic farming."
But the county's organic farms and ranches were still more profitable than traditional growers, Strong said, because Marin residents were willing to pay for locally grown, high quality farm products.
And while the "value added" operations - like cheese-processing plants - encouraged by the county could make farms more profitable, they also require more labor, Strong said.
"A dairy operation with 200 cows might take 12 people to run," Strong said. "A 200-head cow-and-calf operation could be run with one guy or girl."
Despite their economic difficulties, development director Hinds noted that few Marin farmers had expressed any desire to sell or abandon their operations.
"The real tricky part comes during the period of intergenerational transfer," Hinds said. "That's when property could go for sale to people outside the agricultural tradition, since no one within that tradition could easily afford to purchase it. And that's when we come in, trying to understand what protections need to take place."
Those kinds of protections could help to preserve Marin agriculture for another generation, said Bob Berner, executive director of the Marin Agricultural Land Trust.
"Obviously, we cannot determine the viability of agriculture. It's beyond our power or ability," Berner said. "What we can do is to ask whether agricultural land use deserves to be here. If the answer is yes, we can put into place policies that preserve and protect agriculture through incentives and disincentives."
Contact Rob Rogers via e-mail at email@example.com